Under federal law, disabled tenants and prospective tenants with a disability have the right to apply for and live in a rental unit regardless of their impairment. When a landlord rejects disabled tenants based on discriminatory housing practice, they are in violation of the law.
Who Qualifies as Disabled under the Fair Housing Acts?
The federal Fair Housing Act and the Fair Housing Amendments Act (42 U.S. Code §§ 3601-3619, 3631) forbid discrimination of tenants or prospective tenants because of a disability or the disability of a person associated with them. The law protects the following people:
- A person with a mental or physical disability that substantially limits a person’s ability to perform one or more major life activities; or
- A person that has a record of the disability; or
- A person that is considered by others as having the disability
Types of protected disabilities include mobile, visual, and hearing impairments, intellectual disability, alcoholism (if being treated in a recovery program), drug addiction (not caused by the use of an illegal controlled substance), mental illness, HIV, AIDS, and AIDS-Related Complex.
A Landlord May Not Ask Discriminatory Questions.
When a tenant or a prospective tenant has not asked for accommodation, the Fair Housing Acts prohibit the landlord from asking whether the applicant or a person intending to live in the rental has a disability or about the severity of the impairment. Landlords also cannot ask to read medical records. A landlord must treat disabled applicants and tenants in the same way as those without a disability. Consequently, guiding a tenant to a specific rental unit is inappropriate.
However, a landlord may ask all prospective tenants, including disabled applicants, about whether:
- The applicant can meet tenancy requirements;
- The applicant abuses or is addicted to an illegal controlled substance;
- The applicant qualifies for a rental unit available only to people with a disability or a certain type of disability; or
- The applicant qualifies for a rental unit that is offered on a priority basis to people with a disability or with a certain type of disability.
Mental Illness and the Possibility of Direct Threats.
A landlord may not exclude an applicant or tenant because of fear or speculation that the mentally ill person poses a danger. The landlord can assess, however, whether the individual is a direct threat by relying on trustworthy and objective information regarding current conduct or specific acts, such as threats or an assault on another tenant. The landlord must consider several factors, including the nature and severity of the risk of injury, the likelihood of injury, and whether a reasonable accommodation can eliminate the direct threat. The landlord must also consider whether the individual’s receipt of treatment or medication has eliminated the direct threat. If after evaluating reliable and objective evidence the landlord can ascertain that the individual poses a direct threat, then the landlord may reject the individual.
The Right to an Accommodation
Disabled tenants may request the landlord make reasonable accommodations to rules, policies, practices, or services when it will afford the person equal opportunity to use and enjoy the rental unit and the common and public areas. There must be a relationship between the modification and the disability. Reasonable requests include the permission to use a service animal, permission to mail a rent payment rather than personally delivering it to the rental office, or a request to have a parking space large enough for wheelchair access.
A landlord does not have to make accommodations for a reasonable request that is unrelated to a tenant’s disability or for a request that is not reasonable because it will cause an undue financial and administrative burden on the landlord. However, when a request is unreasonable, HUD requires the landlord and the tenant to proceed in an “interactive process” to reach a reasonable compromise.
The Right to Make a Modification
If reasonable, disabled tenants may modify a rental unit to make it safe and comfortable to live in. If the modification will create an inappropriate living condition for the next tenant, the landlord may agree to the modification upon the condition that the tenant restore the unit to its original condition prior to leaving. In this circumstance, the landlord may require the tenant to put money in an interest-bearing escrow account.
All modifications are subject to approval with the landlord. The landlord may ask for a description of the proposed modification and any necessary building permits. Common modifications include wheelchair ramps, lowered countertops, and special door handles.
Phone numbers and websites in NYC for Housing and Tenants rights, courtesy of the US Senate office:
- Affordable Housing Hotline: 212-863-5610. Spanish: 212-863-5620.
- Housing Code Enforcement: 311.
- Mitchell-Lama Program (HPD): 212-863-6500.
- Mitchell-Lama Complaint Line (DHCR): 866-463-7753.
- NYC Housing Authority (NYCHA): 212-306-3000.
- NYCHA nights & weekend repair hotline: 212-289-8000.
- NYC rent guidelines board: 212-385-2934.
- Tenant Information/Advocacy:
Housing court answers: 212-962-4795.
Legal services (assistance with housing court): 646-442-3600.
From the office of the Attorney General, information on fair housing laws and protection for those with disabilities: http://www.ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/pdfs/publications/fair_housing_brochure.pdf.
Fair Housing Justice Center: http://www.fairhousingjustice.org/.
Supported Housing Guidelines NY Gov: http://www.omh.ny.gov/omhweb/adults/SupportedHousing/supportedhousingguidelines.html. Phone Number: 800-597-8481.
Landlord/Tenant information is provided free of cost from Friedman & Ranzenhoffer Attorneys at Law: http://www.wny-lawyers.com/buffalo-new-york-landlord-tenant-attorneys/landlordtenant-websites/. Phone number: 716-542-5444.
General Helpline Phone Number: 800-771-7755.